Lucky the Banker mascotLTB
Series 79: Collection, Analysis & Evaluation of Data
Series 79 practice questionmediumComparable Company Analysis

A banker is screening for comparable companies to value a mid-cap manufacturing firm. One potential peer operates in a similar industry but derives 60% of its revenue from highly cyclical commodity sales, while the target derives 90% from stable, long-term contracts. Which is the best course of action for the banker regarding this peer, and why?

  1. AInclude the peer without adjustment, because industry classification is sufficient.
  2. BConsider excluding or adjusting the peer, since differences in revenue stability can distort valuation multiples.✓ Correct answer
  3. CInclude the peer but only use forward-looking metrics for comparison.
  4. DExclude all peers with any commodity exposure regardless of size or segment mix.
Explanation

Why BConsider excluding or adjusting the peer, since differences in revenue stability can distort valuation multiples.

Significant differences in revenue cyclicality can meaningfully impact valuation multiples, so peers with distinct business models should be excluded or adjusted. Including such a peer without consideration could lead to misleading conclusions, which is a common trap for less careful analysts.

Turn it into reps

Reading one answer is not the same as being ready

Lucky the Banker is a free practice app with 995+ Series 79 questions, weak-area tracking, and timed mock exams. No credit card, no paywall.

Spot an error in this question or explanation? Tell us — we fix these fast.

Related Collection, Analysis & Evaluation of Data questions